Forget The Cybertruck: These 2 Tesla Models Are More Affordable To Own Over 5 Years
Tesla CEO Elon Musk first introduced the Cybertruck with its one-of-a-kind geometric design in November 2019, when he boasted a base model full of features for $39,900. That price never materialized, and in February 2026, Tesla launched a Dual Motor trim at $59,990, then raised it by $10,000 just 10 days later. Today, the 2026 Cybertruck's MSRP starts at $72,235, and a typically equipped one costs around $88,325 to own over five years, according to CarEdge. But if you're willing to do without the eye-catching appearance, you could save more by opting for either the Tesla Model 3 or Model Y.
EVs might have higher sticker prices than gas-powered vehicles, but they can help drivers save on long-term expenses like fuel and maintenance. The Model 3's pricing starts around $38,630, and the Model Y around $41,630 – both modest compared to the Cybertruck. The five-year cost of ownership for the Model 3 and Model Y is around $57,567 and $65,104, respectively, including depreciation, insurance, maintenance, fuel, and loan interest. In addition to the upfront cost, you could also save more on insurance, maintenance, and EV charging with these more affordable Tesla models.
Tesla Cybertruck vs. Model 3 vs. Model Y: Costs of ownership
According to U.S. News, Teslas are some of the fastest-depreciating vehicles, due to frequent price adjustments and design changes, sometimes made with no notice. The Cybertruck depreciates by approximately $43,539 in the first five years. The Tesla Model 3 loses about $31,244, and the Model Y loses about $30,772. But if you're planning to keep your Tesla for a while, other expenses might be more important than a loss of value.
Insure.com reports that insuring a Cybertruck costs an average of $4,415 a year, compared with $3,871 for the Model 3 and $3,836 for the Model Y. Teslas might be more expensive to insure than other vehicles because they cost more to repair or replace after a major accident. That said, regular maintenance costs are affordable, with the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y ranking as CarEdge's first and second cheapest luxury cars to maintain. Tesla estimates that annual maintenance costs for the Model 3 are between $257 and $499, and between $316 and $643 for the Model Y.
Since Teslas are electric, they can save you money on gas and should only minimally increase your electric bill. Autoblog estimates that a Cybertruck costs approximately $0.07 per mile if you're charging it at home. The Model 3 and Model Y cost closer to $0.04 per mile. Overall, the Model 3 and Model Y can provide a more affordable luxury experience.