Consumer Reports' List Of Best Cheap Cars, Ranked By Reliability

Affordability is a central concern for people when searching for a new vehicle. An Edmunds survey revealed that nearly two-thirds of Americans delay purchasing a car due to higher price tags. Although vehicles consistently rank among a household's largest investments, newfound sticker shock is completely justified, as the entire market experiences inflationary price surges. According to CarEdge, the average cost of a new vehicle is an eye-popping $48,749. That represents around a 30% surge over the past five years. With the prices of essential household items jumping, consumers have less discretionary income to put towards a new vehicle, making them more skeptical of cars on the higher end of the price range.

Consumer Reports recently looked at the extensive line of 2025 car models to determine the most reliable models that fall in the more affordable range. Analysts gather information from driver surveys taken by members of Consumer Reports. These questionnaires ask drivers about their first-hand experiences with certain car brands and individual models. These questions are designed to gauge how owners view the reliability of the vehicles in different aspects. The data remains up to date, and the surveys are extensive. In 2024 alone, information on the reliability of over 300,000 vehicles was retrieved and analyzed.

The focus on both affordability and dependability is a common razor consumers use to cut through the fat and narrow their options. Instead of simply looking at sticker prices, Consumer Reports analysts dug into various pricing mechanisms to determine a more accurate, average price. This way, you can be sure you'll have a better chance of replicating these deals in real life rather than being disappointed when the online or lot price differs greatly.

The Toyota Corolla Hatchback kicks off Consumer Reports' list of the cheapest, reliable vehicles. The spin on the standard Corolla model — famed for its fuel economy, reasonable size, and cost-effectiveness — bears many of the same advantages as its inspiration. In fact, it's the sedan's reputation that drove Consumer Reports to grant the 2025 Hatchback an enviable 84 out of 100 reliability rating, meaning it is expected to be more dependable than the average new car in the long run. The vehicle's fuel economy, clocking in at 36 miles per gallon, and overall driving experience are standout features, although its noisier ride and smaller rear seat are important considerations.

While acknowledging the Hatchback's slightly smaller size compared to the sedan, Kelley Blue Book (KBB) underscores the increased flexibility offered in the vehicle's unique rear design, opening up users to more cargo options. Furthermore, KBB points to the model's high engine quality and its ability to maintain its resale value over time. The Hatchback's slightly smaller frame could end up saving consumers a little bit of cash, with a price range of $23,780 to $27,080, slightly under the Corolla sedan's sticker. You're still on the hook for a $1,160 destination fee if you have it shipped to you. This model features the same standard and powertrain warranties as its sedan counterpart. 

As a whole, the Toyota brand lost its top spot for reliability in Consumer Reports' eyes, but the automaker still has individual models turning heads. The Corolla model has a proven track record as a trustworthy car. Year after year, it has been one of Toyota's best-selling brands and stands as the most-produced car under the brand, with over 53 million released. Consumer Reports gave the 2025 edition an 84 out of 100 for reliability, highlighting the vehicle's suspension, steering, powertrain, and electronic features. The newest Corolla boasts an economical 36 miles per gallon fuel efficiency, further lowering an owner's all-in costs over time. 

Digging a little deeper, J.D. Power highlights the vehicle's spaciousness and layout versatility, featuring a dynamic 60/40-split rear seat. The standard suite of safety features in Toyota Safety 3.0 helps monitor objects around the vehicle. With a price range between $22,325 and $28,190, consumers are looking at a reasonable deal for leading reliability. Don't forget about the $1,160 charge for shipping the vehicle straight from the dealership, although you can skirt this cost by picking it up in person or buying from a local dealership. The newest Corolla also comes with various warranties, including a three-year, 36,000-mile standard warranty and a five-year, 60,000-mile powertrain version, offering some nice peace of mind. 

Mazda was the first popular car manufacturer to stop production in the U.S. after tariffs. However, the 2025 Mazda3 model had already been released to the American people, giving budget-conscious consumers another reliable option. This sporty sedan receives a 72 for reliability from Consumer Reports, owing to the vehicle's suite of high-rated features, including build quality, powertrain, brakes, suspension, and steering. Even the model's climate system received high marks, although its built-in electronics were found lacking.

Edmunds underscores the model's comfortable interior and driving experience, while acknowledging its refined style at an economical price point. Drivers looking for a little more control and capability can upgrade to the all-wheel drive Mazda3 with a turbocharged engine. Similar to Consumer Reports, Edmunds analysts give two thumbs down to the vehicle's electronics, arguing the center display isn't viable as a touchscreen due to its distance from the driver. You can drive away in a 2025 Mazda3 for as low as $24,150, although some upgrades raise the price to $37,150. Regardless, you'll be on the line for $1,235 in shipping costs, unless buying from a dealership in person. RepairPal estimates the annual maintenance costs of a Mazda3 are only around $433, furthering your savings in the long run. Notably, the Mazda3 has seen one recall. While by no means one of the largest car recalls in history, it's still something for consumers to consider. 

With a Consumer Reports reliability rating of 63 and a price tag ranging between $21,590 and $24,590, the 2025 Nissan Sentra is a suitable middle-of-the-road model, balancing between dependability and affordability. If you're buying straight from the manufacturer, you'll incur an additional $1,195 flat fee for transportation, which still keeps the overall price extremely reasonable given the vehicle's features. The model is praised by analysts for its riding performance, with particular attention paid to its handling, controls, and braking. The 32 miles per gallon fuel economy is another area of note among Consumer Reports' coverage. Despite some downvotes on the 2025 Nissan Sentra's front seat support, headlights, and parking brake, the publication judged the vehicle to be "the best Sentra we've ever tested."

KBB struck a more moderate tone, calling the model "a good car amongst greats." Soberly, the leading car research brand acknowledges where the Sentra excels: as an economical sedan. Instead of pricey bells and whistles, the focus is on doing the basics well. Staying in its own lane has paid off for the Nissan Sentra, ranking seventh among the most fuel-efficient sedans and ninth among the best compact cars, according to KBB. The cost of owning a 2025 Sentra is also considerably affordable, with estimates placing annual repair costs at $491. All in all, this car is so affordable that many consumers might not have to take out a loan, which is one of the unfortunate truths about buying a new car.

Consumer Reports places Kia ninth among nearly two dozen other car brands for new car reliability. More specifically, the Soul offers a 58 out of 100 for dependability. This above-average ranking is owed to the vehicle's quality powertrain, brakes, suspension, and steering. The car's characteristic boxy shape is more than just a head-turner and unique flair. It makes the Soul compact on the outside for easier maneuvering and livability, while offering a spacious interior layout for multiple passengers and increased comfort. The Kia Soul's in-vehicle electronics and overall build quality drag down its reliability. Edmunds echoes Consumer Reports' comments regarding the Soul's roomy inside and smooth handling, noting its "one of the best subcompacts out there." When you take the Soul out on the highway, abnormally audible road and wind noise can ruin an otherwise smooth ride. Furthermore, there's only one engine option available, leaving consumers looking for add-ons. 

A brand new Soul weighs in at $20,490 to $24,790, not applying too much pressure to your wallet, considering the average cost of a vehicle. The transportation fee for ordering from the dealership is a typical $1,445. Not shopping around is one of the ways you're destroying your budget without even knowing it, so don't be shy about looking at different dealerships for the best Soul price. Another place you can save is on the warranties. Kia offers some of the most competitive warranties on the market, providing customers with a 10-year, 100,000-mile powertrain warranty, a five-year, 60,000-mile new vehicle option, and — for the hybrid option — a 10-year, 100,000-mile EV system warranty.

The 2025 Nissan Versa lands at one of the lowest price points on this list of Consumer Reports' cheapest, reliable cars. A new model ranges between $17,190 and $21,190. Even with a $1,195 delivery charge from the dealership, this wallet-friendly car still comes in lower than competitors. The model furthers its economic reputation with a respectable 32 miles per gallon. The annual repair costs to keep a 2025 Versa running properly are only around $456, which isn't too considerable spread out across an entire year.

The Versa's 50 out of 100 for reliability means Consumer Reports analysts expect it to deliver average dependability, offering customers a mixed bag of advantages and considerations. In terms of driving experience, the Versa does the fundamentals well, and that's about it. The controls, fuel efficiency, and standard automatic emergency braking (AEB) check off the standard requirements, but the affordable Nissan doesn't have much to show in the way of a comfortable ride. The seats aren't the most supportive, and the engine is loud, especially at higher speeds.

U.S. News & World Report praises the car's sizable cargo space, decent suite of features — even if they're standard — and solid build, yet bemoans the model's lack of changes over the years. Despite these criticisms, it ranks number one on the site's list of subcompact cars. In summary, the 2025 Nissan Versa offers one of the best bang-for-your-buck deals on the market for drivers who don't mind giving up some comfort or advanced features.

The Hyundai Venue straddles the midpoint in reliability, scoring a 50 out of 100, according to Consumer Reports' rankings. This standard dependability places the model on par with the rest of the automobile industry, which means consumers need to really pay attention to the specifics. Don't be fooled by the vehicle's modest exterior; the inside offers a deceptive amount of room. Whether you're packing away belongings or having some friends tag along, the hatchback design of the Venue offers generous flexibility. That being said, analysts complain about the rear seat's uncomfortable design, the lackluster finish, and the lack of adjustable anchors for seatbelts. Beyond that, drivers have complained about the noisy and rough ride. On a positive note, Consumer Reports highlights the Venue's intuitive audio and climate controls, premium safety features, and above-average forward visibility. 

The higher-than-normal 32 miles per gallon fuel economy is another major plus, especially for those looking to shave a few dollars off their monthly budgets. After all, having the right car is one of the most effective tricks to save you money at the pump. Speaking of affordability, the Hyundai Venue ranges in value between $20,200 and $23,450, placing it far below the national standard price for new vehicles. With that starting price, the $1,495 destination fee doesn't even look too bad. MotorTrend doesn't sugarcoat its review of the 2025 Venue, calling the feel of the vehicle "cheap and basic." However, it acknowledges how Hyundai has succeeded in providing an uber-affordable vehicle, an area where most automakers fail considerably. Buying a new Venue does offer some protection, with Hyundai offering a host of warranties for anti-perforation, roadside assistance, and powertrain.

The 2025 Hyundai Elantra is a serious upgrade from previous models, according to Consumer Reports. Don't let the sedan's 45 out of 100 reliability rating scare you off, as it punches well above its price tag. Depending on the model, the new Elantra tends to go for $22,125 on the low end and up to $35,850 on the upper end. All options within the 2025 Elantra model offer a robust transmission with ergonomic controls, responsive braking, smooth handling, and impressive 33 miles per gallon fuel economy. The downsides of a loud engine and noisy ride are escapable with the hybrid model, even bumping up the Elantra's already stellar fuel efficiency. Consumer Reports analysts also call attention to the model's user-friendly entertainment system.

KBB reiterates the Elantra's premium transmission and ride experience, yet goes a step further to highlight the vehicle's safety features. It offers automatic braking response to prevent forward collisions. The blind-spot sensors warn drivers and passengers of potential obstacles for safe turns, lane changes, and exits from the vehicle. Furthermore, the driving assist function helps keep the 2025 Elantra centered within a single lane, working to prevent veering. Elantra purchasers will also benefit from the brand's numerous warranties, including a 10-year, 100,000-mile powertrain warranty, a seven-year, unlimited miles anti-perforation warranty, and a five-year, unlimited miles roadside assistance warranty.

With a 44 out of 100 for reliability, the 2025 Kia Seltos closes out Consumer Reports' list of the most dependable, affordable vehicles. While receiving the lowest ranking on this list, Kia is ranked as the ninth-most-reliable new car on the researcher's site. This brand trustworthiness extends to the Seltos model specifically, which is championed for its suspension, steering, climate system, and overall build quality. Consumer Reports celebrates the tiny SUV's versatile design, spacious interior, and 28 miles per gallon fuel economy — impressive for its vehicle class. However, analysts are quick to note the poor riding experience and noisiness.

Car and Driver piggybacks on Consumer Reports' criticism, pointing to the subpar driving of the Seltos. Analysts think the standard engine falls shy of moderate expectations, allowing competitor models to easily surpass it. Drivers looking to compensate for this blind spot can pay a little extra for an all-wheel-drive version of the Seltos. There are even trim upgrades for a more stylish interior and Bose speakers for a concert-quality sound. Off the lot, the 2025 Kia Seltos ranges between $24,690 and $31,190, making it an extremely affordable model. The average maintenance cost for a 2025 Seltos is a reasonable $474.